Method comparison
Each sheet lifting method suits different material, surface and access conditions. This comparison helps you understand which method can be considered for your needs.
The table is a general starting point; suitability is determined by the actual load and operating conditions.
| Criterion | Mechanical clamp | Vacuum lifter | Magnetic lifter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Suitable material | Plates and edges that suit the clamp design; can include non-steel materials. | Surfaces that allow an airtight seal; can include non-steel materials. | Iron and steel materials suitable for magnetic holding. |
| Gripping point | Plate edge. | Plate surface. | Plate surface. |
| Surface condition | Edge condition and edge access matter. | Holes, roughness and porosity affect the seal. | Paint, rust, roughness and air gaps affect holding. |
| Access | Needs edge access; requires side clearance in a stack. | Access from the top surface. | Access from the top surface. |
| Perforated / cut parts | Depends on part geometry. | Holes can reduce the contact area. | Assessed by the remaining contact area. |
| Power and control | Usually works mechanically. | Requires vacuum generation and controls that depend on system design. | Depends on system type: electromagnetic, EPM or permanent magnet. |
An adjustable handling layout for different sheet and plate lengths.
Lifting solutions that need no fixed power cable running to the load.
Systems assessed by handling direction and sheet dimensions.
About sheet lifting methods.
Whether the material is magnetic, the contact condition of the surface, the proportion of holes and cut-outs, and access conditions are assessed together. Magnetic systems are not suitable for non-steel materials.
A clamp can be considered when the plate edge is accessible and gripping cannot be done from the surface. Clamp selection depends on plate thickness and handling direction.
QSMAGNET offers magnetic lifting and robotic magnetic gripping solutions. This comparison is designed to help you assess whether a magnetic solution suits your needs.
Share your material, dimensions and working method; let’s define the right method together.
